Moneycontrol vs Phantom: which trading tool
Moneycontrol replies to 97% of unhappy reviews on Google Play, Phantom to 82%. Phantom does not read your SMS; Moneycontrol does. Over the last 90 days of reviews, Moneycontrol averages 2.76 and Phantom 2.88. The most serious complaint about Moneycontrol is "Pushed into things"; about Phantom, "none found".
| Moneycontrol | Phantom | |
|---|---|---|
| Most serious thing people report | Pushed into things (4 of 370) | none found |
| Does anyone answer complaints | 97% of low-star reviews · usually same day | 82% of low-star reviews · median 6d |
| Rating in the last 90 days | 2.76 (down 0.74 on lifetime) | 2.88 (down 1.60 on lifetime) |
| Last updated | this month | this month |
| Reads your SMS | yes | no |
| Reads your contacts | no | no |
| Shows ads | yes | no |
| Numbers confirmed on a register | 0 of 2 | none published |
| Charges we could source | not extracted yet | not extracted yet |
| Charges only in the terms | not extracted yet | not extracted yet |
How to read this
Every row comes from a public source: the app store listings, the reviews people left there, and the registers kept by RBI, SEBI and IRDAI. Where a row says "Not known", we have not measured it yet, which is different from the answer being no. Qrates takes no commission from either app.
Full pages: Moneycontrol · Phantom